Saturday, December 30, 2006

Batteries – Primary and Secondary Batteries – Materials, Advantages and Disadvantages

Types of Batteries

Batteries can be divided into two types: primary or disposable batteries and secondary or rechargeable batteries.

Advantages of Batteries over Fuel Cells

The main advantages of batteries over fuel cells are their:

· Availability

· Portability

· Low cost

· Wide range of operating conditions

Disadvantages of Batteries When Compared to Fuel Cells

Batteries, however, have much shorter life spans and lack the power output of fuel cells. Power outputs of batteries are typically on the order of 100's of watts, whereas fuel cells can provide kilowatt to megawatt outputs, power enough to light a building or fuel a vehicle for hours. Under heavy energy demands, batteries can build up dangerous levels of heat and pressure, degrading the battery and possibly causing leaks of toxic compounds or even explosions. In addition, the limited life of primary batteries and the limited cycle life (number of times it can be recharged) of most secondary batteries necessitates the need for disposal of often dangerous and toxic battery materials.

Common Types of Primary and Secondary Batteries

Table 1 summarizes some of the common types of primary and secondary batteries.

Table 1. Some common types of Batteries.

Battery Type

Anode

Cathode

Electrolyte

Advantages

Disadvantages

Primary Batteries

Alkaline Cell

Zn

MnO2

KOH

High energy density, long shelf life, good leak resistance, performs well under heavy or light use.

Costlier than zinc-carbon cell but more efficient

Aluminum/Air Cell

Al

O2

KOH or neutral salt solution

Can operate exposed to sea water (neutral salt solution), easily replaceable electrolytes/electrodes

Anode quickly degrades, short shelf life, short operational life

Leclanché Cell (Zinc Carbon or Dry Cell)

Zn

MnO2

NH4Cl or ZnCl2

Cheap and common (oldest available battery type)

Poor performance under heavy or continuous use.

Lithium Cell

Li

Various liquid or solid materials

SOCl2, SO2Cl2, or organic solutions

Very high energy density, long shelf life, long operational life

Poor performance under heavy use, vulnerable to leaks or explosions

Mercury Oxide Cell

Zn or Cd

HgO

KOH

Higher energy density than (Zn/MnO2) alkaline cell

High cost and being phased out due to toxicity concerns

Zinc/Air Cell

Zn

O2

KOH

Environmentally benign, cheap, very high energy density, and virtually unlimited shelf life

Short operational life, low power density

Secondary (rechargeable) Batteries

Iron Nickel Cell

Fe

Ni(OH)2

KOH

Long life under a variety of conditions, excellent back-up battery

Low rate-performance, slow recharge rate

Lead/Acid Cell

Pb

PbO2

dilute H2SO4(aq)

Low cost, long life cycle, operates well under a variety of conditions. Common car batteries

Minor risk of leakage

Lithium Ion Cell

C, carbon compounds

Li2O, intercalated into graphite

LiPF6, LiBF4, related compounds

Relatively cheap, high energy density, long shelf life, long operational life, long cycle life

Minor risk of leakage

Nickel/Cadmium Cell

Cd

Ni(OH)2

KOH

Good performance under heavy discharge and/or low temperature

High cost, can temporary loose cell capacity if not fully discharged before recharging (memory effect)

Nickel/Metal Hydride (NiMH) Cell

Lanthanide or Ni alloys

Ni(OH)2

KOH

High capacity and power density

High cost, some memory effect

Nickel/Zinc Cell

Zn

NiO

KOH

Low cost, low toxicity, good for high discharge rates

Zinc on the electrolyte tends to redeposit unevenly on anode, severely reducing efficiency

Sodium/Sulfur Cell

Molten Na

Molten S

Al2O3

Inexpensive materials, long cycle life, high energy and power

High operational temperature lower efficiency, some danger of explosion upon degradation


Primary Components of a Battery

The primary component materials of a battery are the anode, cathode, electrolyte, and semi-permeable materials. In addition various catalysts have been used to enhance the performance of electrodes. For example, ruthenium(IV) oxide is used as a catalyst in a vanadium redox battery system. Table 1 summarizes some of the types of electrodes and electrolytes used in common batteries. Many advanced battery designs focus upon new materials for these key components.
Lithium Ion Batteries

Much of the recent battery work has focused on lithium-ion batteries, since they are the primary power source for the ever-growing field of small, rechargeable electronic devices. Nickel sulfide (Aldrich product 34,247-5), for example, was recently explored as a cathode material for rechargeable lithium batteries.2 Current research is also concerned with some very mundane materials in electrodes. New morphologies of graphite flakes, as a case in point, have been studied as anode material in lithium-ion batteries.3 Electrolytes are also very important in battery performance. An LiBF4 solution, for example in a butyrolacetone/ethylene carbonate solution has proven to be a highly conductive and highly thermally stable electrolyte for lithium-ion batteries.